The Only Time a Roth Conversion Is Actually Worth It

Name the Tax You're Beating — The Only Time a Roth Conversion Is Actually Worth It | Masuda Lehrman Wealth

By Daniel Masuda Lehrman, CFP®

If you're thinking about a Roth conversion this year, you have until December 31. After that, the window for this tax year closes. And once you convert, you can't undo it.

That makes the next few weeks one of the most important stretches on the calendar for a lot of retirees. It's also when I see the most expensive mistakes, because people rush to convert without asking one simple question.

What tax, exactly, am I trying to beat?

If you can answer that, a Roth conversion can lower your taxes for years to come. If you can't, it's often just paying the IRS early for the privilege of feeling proactive.

If you're somewhere in the middle, unsure whether this even applies to you, you're not behind. Most people I talk to are exactly there.

I'm Daniel Masuda Lehrman, a fee-only CFP® in Honolulu, and I work with people in the years right before and after retirement. In this article I'll walk you through the one test that decides whether a conversion is worth it, the years when it's cheapest, and how to know when to stop.

What We'll Cover

  • The test — the one question that decides whether a Roth conversion is worth it
  • The window — the ages when conversions are cheapest, and the traps on either side
  • The line — how much to convert, and where to stop
  • The bill — how to pay the tax without undoing the benefit

A while back, I wrote about which retirees should be converting. This one is about when and how much.

The Roth Conversion Test: Name the Tax You're Beating

Here's the only time a Roth conversion is actually worth it: when the rate you pay today is lower than the rate that same money would face later, and you can name that later rate.

Not "taxes will probably go up." A specific tax, at a specific rate, in a specific situation.

What a Real Reason Sounds Like

  • "I'm paying 12% now so I don't pay 22% at 75, when my required distributions stack on top of Social Security."
  • "I'm paying 22% now so my wife doesn't pay 24% or 32% on the same money after I'm gone and she's filing single."
  • "I'm paying 24% now so my kids don't pay 32% on it in their peak earning years."

Each of those names the specific tax it's avoiding. That's a real reason.

What It Sounds Like When It Fails

"I'm paying 24% now because I hate the idea of RMDs." Or: "I'm converting because everyone on YouTube says to."

Now, to be fair to the "taxes are going up" argument, there's a legitimate version of it. Tax law can and does change, and having some money in Roth accounts gives you flexibility no matter what Congress decides to do. A modest amount of conversion for that flexibility is reasonable.

But a guess about future tax law is not a great reason to pay 24% or 32% today on a large chunk of your IRA.

So here's the verdict: if you can finish the sentence "I'm paying this rate now so I don't pay that rate later on this," a conversion may make sense. If you can't, you're allowed to skip it.

The Window: When Roth Conversions Are Cheapest

Think about retirement like climbing a mountain. Thirty years of climbing, then the summit, then the descent. The conversion window is the stretch of trail right after the summit — after the paycheck stops and before Social Security and required distributions start. For a lot of people, it's the lowest-income stretch they'll have for the rest of their lives.

But the window has traps on both ends, and this is where people get hurt.

Trap 1: Converting While You're Still Working

Every dollar you convert lands on top of your salary, usually at your highest rate. For most people, that's the most expensive time to convert, not the cheapest.

Trap 2: Converting Before 65 on a Marketplace Health Plan

Conversions count as income for your health insurance subsidy. Under the rules in effect for 2026 coverage, a couple loses the entire premium tax credit above about $84,600 of income (400% of the federal poverty level). I wrote a whole article on health insurance from 62 to 65, and the short version is that for most people on a marketplace plan, the subsidy wins and the conversions wait.

Trap 3: Medicare's Two-Year Lookback (IRMAA)

IRMAA, the Medicare premium surcharge, is based on your income from two years earlier. So conversions from the year you turn 63 onward can raise your Medicare premiums. For a married couple, the first surcharge tier starts above $218,000 of income in 2026. That's a line to know, not a reason to panic.

Trap 4: Social Security Taxation

Once Social Security starts, every dollar you convert can also make more of your benefit taxable, which quietly raises the real rate you're paying on the conversion.

The Sweet Spot

So where's the sweet spot, if all four of those traps are out there? For a lot of retirees, it's from 65 until Social Security starts — Medicare in place, no paycheck, no Social Security income yet, and required distributions still years away. If you were born in 1960 or later, RMDs don't start until 75.

That's why delaying Social Security and converting in the gap years so often go together. The delay creates the window, and the window helps pay for the delay. Delaying does have a cost: you need other assets to live on in the meantime, which is exactly the role a taxable account plays below.

The Line: How Much to Convert, and Where to Stop

Let me show you what I mean with real numbers.

Meet James and Kim

James and Kim are a hypothetical couple. Both 66, both retired. They have $1.6 million in IRAs and about $600,000 in a taxable brokerage account. They've decided to delay Social Security to 70, when they'll receive about $80,000 a year combined. In the meantime, they live on the brokerage account.

If They Do Nothing

If their IRA grows at 5% a year, it's worth about $2.5 million by 75. Their first required distribution is that balance divided by 24.6, or about $101,000. Stack that on top of their Social Security, and their taxable income lands around $133,000. That's well into the 22% bracket, and their federal tax is roughly $18,700 a year, rising from there.

That's the named rate. Twenty-two percent, at 75 and beyond.

And how long is "beyond"? Longer than most people plan for. According to the Social Security Administration, about one in three 65-year-olds today will live past 90, and about one in seven will live past 95. For a married couple, the odds that at least one of them gets there are higher still. So that 22% isn't a one-year problem. It can run for twenty years or more, and as the required percentage rises every year, the bill tends to grow with it.

If They Fill the 12% Bracket

Right now, with almost no other income, they have a lot of room in the low brackets. Between the 2026 standard deduction ($32,200), the extra deduction for being over 65 ($1,650 each), and the new senior deduction ($6,000 each, currently scheduled through 2028), their first $47,500 or so of income isn't taxed at all. The 12% bracket then runs to $100,800 of taxable income.

So they can convert about $138,000 a year and stay inside the 12% bracket. The federal tax on that conversion is about $11,600:

$11,600 ÷ $138,000 ≈ 8.4 cents on the dollar.

Say they do that every year from 66 to 70. That's about $690,000 converted, for about $58,000 in total federal tax.

Here's what it can buy them. At 75, their IRA is about $1.5 million instead of $2.5 million. Their first required distribution drops to about $61,000. Their taxable income stays inside the 12% bracket, and their federal tax is roughly $10,500 a year instead of $18,700 — about $8,000 less per year from there on, if their assumptions hold.

And sitting next to it is a Roth account of nearly $1 million that grows tax-free, has no required distributions for the owner, and can pass to the survivor or the kids without an income-tax bill attached.

That's the test passing. Twelve percent now to avoid 22% later.

What Happens If They Get Greedy

So if 12% works this well, why not convert even more? Say they decide to "get it done faster" and convert $300,000 in one year. Every dollar above that first $138,000 lands in the 22% and 24% brackets, and it wipes out the senior deduction on the way. That extra $162,000 costs about $39,000 in federal tax — roughly 24 cents on the dollar. And two years later, their Medicare premiums jump by nearly $5,800 for the year because they crossed the IRMAA line.

They'd be paying 24% to avoid 22%. That fails the test.

Where to Stop

Convert up to the point where today's rate stops beating tomorrow's rate, and stop there. For James and Kim, that's the top of the 12% bracket. For someone with a bigger balance, or a survivor to protect, it might be the top of the 22%. The line is wherever your named rate is.

And notice what James and Kim didn't do. They didn't try to empty the IRA. They still have $1.5 million of pre-tax money at 75, and that's fine, because the goal was never to pay zero tax later. The goal was to stop paying 22% on money they could have moved at 12%. Converting deliberately to the right line almost always beats converting everything.

The Bill: How to Pay the Tax on a Roth Conversion

The last piece is the one people skip, and it can quietly undo the whole thing. Where does the money for the tax actually come from?

Pay the conversion tax from money outside the IRA.

If you convert $138,000 and have the tax withheld from the conversion itself, less money lands in the Roth, and you've given up some of the tax-free growth you were paying for. And if you're under 59½, the amount withheld can also be hit with a 10% early withdrawal penalty.

That's why the taxable brokerage account is so valuable in the conversion years. James and Kim pay their $11,600 a year from the brokerage account, and the full $138,000 goes into the Roth. If you don't have outside money to pay the tax, the case for converting gets weaker, and that belongs in your test too.

Two Practical Notes

  • Timing within the year. You can't undo a conversion anymore, so a lot of people wait until November or December, when they know what the year's income actually looks like.
  • State taxes. If you live in a state with an income tax, Hawaii included, add the state rate to both sides of the test. If there's a real chance you'll move to a no-income-tax state later, that belongs in the comparison too.

You Have Permission to Convert — or to Skip It

Here's what I want you to hear. A Roth conversion is a price you choose to pay today, because you can see a higher price later.

If you can name that bigger price, convert on purpose, to the right line. You're not being aggressive. You're choosing your tax rate instead of letting someone else choose it later.

And if you can't name it, you have my permission to skip it. Not converting is a perfectly good decision when you make it deliberately.

Name the Tax You're Beating. Then Decide.

Here's the whole article in one sentence. Try it on your own numbers:

"I'm paying ___% now, so I don't pay ___% later, on ___."

If you can fill in all three blanks, that's the only time a Roth conversion is actually worth it. The window tells you when. The line tells you how much. And paying from outside money makes sure you keep what you paid for.

What the conversion really buys isn't a smaller tax bill for its own sake. It's flexibility later: a pool of money you can spend in any year without moving your bracket, triggering a Medicare surcharge, or leaving a tax bill for whoever comes after you.

And remember, conversions are an annual decision. It's not one and done.

Run Your Own Conversion Numbers

If you'd like help running your own Roth conversion numbers — your brackets, your Social Security timing, your Medicare line, and what happens for the survivor — you can schedule a free consultation at masudalehrman.com/contact. I work with clients in Honolulu and virtually across the country. You can also start with the free Retirement Readiness Assessment to see where you stand before we talk.

— Daniel Masuda Lehrman, CFP®, Founder of Masuda Lehrman Wealth. Mahalo for reading.

James and Kim are a hypothetical example for illustration only. The figures use simplified, approximate federal-only assumptions (2026 tax law, about $10,000 of other income, 5% annual growth) and do not represent an actual client or guarantee any outcome. Tax rules, including Medicare and health-insurance subsidy thresholds, change; coordinate any conversion with your tax professional.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not personalized financial, tax, or legal advice.

Free Guide: The Retirement Income Blueprint

Enjoyed this article? Get my free guide on turning your savings into a retirement paycheck you can't outlive — covering your income gap, withdrawal strategy, Social Security timing, and more.

About Daniel Masuda Lehrman, CFP®

Prior to starting my own firm, I was a Vice President Financial Consultant at Charles Schwab in their Downtown Honolulu office. I have worked in financial planning for 10 years at Vanguard, Fidelity, and Schwab. I'm a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ professional with an Economics degree from the University of Michigan.

Schedule a meeting