How Much Should You Have Saved by 60? The Honest Answer to When Can I Retire

IT'S NOT 8X YOUR SALARY — How Much Should You Have Saved by 60? The Honest Answer to When Can I Retire | Masuda Lehrman Wealth

By Daniel Masuda Lehrman, CFP®

Eight times your salary.

If you've spent any time on retirement websites, you've probably seen that benchmark. By 60, you should have eight times your salary saved. Make $150,000 a year? That's $1.2 million. It's the most common shortcut people use to answer the question "when can I retire?"

And maybe you've done the math on yourself and felt a little queasy, because you're not there. Or maybe you're way past it, and you're wondering why you don't quite believe it or don't feel ready.

Either way, you're not alone. The benchmark is a rule of thumb answering a different question than the one you're asking.

Here's the brutally honest version. That number isn't built from what your retirement will cost. It's built from your paycheck. Paycheck does not equal lifestyle. And for two couples with the exact same salary, the honest number at 60 can differ by more than a million and a half dollars.

I'm Daniel Masuda Lehrman, a Certified Financial Planner and founder of a fee-only planning firm here in Honolulu. Before that, I spent years at Vanguard, Fidelity, and Schwab, handing people charts exactly like this one. In this article, I'll show you what that benchmark actually measures, where it misleads, and how to build your honest number at 60 in about five minutes.

To get there, we need to pull apart three things that usually get blurred together:

  • What the 8x benchmark actually measures — and what it doesn't
  • Why salary is the wrong ruler for most people
  • And how to build the honest number for retiring at 60, not 67

The third one is where most people find out they're either much closer than they thought, or much further away.

What 8x Your Salary Actually Means: A Checkpoint, Not a Finish Line

Let's start by being fair to the benchmark, because it's not a bad tool.

The version most people have seen comes from Fidelity: one times your salary by 30, three times by 40, six by 50, eight by 60, and ten by 67. It's simple, it's easy to remember, and for a 35-year-old trying to figure out if they're saving enough, it's genuinely helpful.

But look at the assumptions underneath it. Fidelity assumes you save 15% of your pay every year starting at 25. It assumes you retire at 67. It assumes your savings need to replace about 45% of your pre-retirement income, with Social Security covering much of the rest, and no pension. And it's built to hold up even in poor markets, with a planning horizon out to age 93.

Now notice what that means for the number at 60. Eight times your salary isn't the amount that says you can retire at 60. It's the checkpoint that says you're on track to retire at 67, seven years from now.

Fidelity's own guideline says retiring at 65 takes closer to twelve times your salary. So retiring at 60 takes more than that.

Why does that matter so much? Because those last seven years are some of the most powerful in the whole savings formula. They're usually your highest-earning years, you're allowed catch-up contributions, and the balance is big enough that growth does a lot of the work. Take all of that away and the math changes completely.

A lot of people hit 8x, feel done, and don't realize the benchmark assumed seven more years of paychecks, contributions, and growth.

So 8x at 60 is a reasonable checkpoint for someone working to 67. It's not an answer for someone who wants to stop at 60.

But here's where it gets more interesting, because even at 67, the salary part is where the benchmark really starts to break.

Salary Is the Wrong Ruler for Retirement Income Planning

Here's the thing you have to understand. Your retirement doesn't cost a multiple of your salary. It costs a multiple of your spending.

And for most people, those two numbers are very different.

Two Couples, Same Salary

Meet two hypothetical couples. Both are 60, and both households earn $150,000 a year. So the benchmark hands them both the same target: $1.2 million by 60, and about $1.5 million by 67.

Ray and Sakura have been savers their whole lives. The house is paid off, they drive their cars for twelve years, and when they pull their statements, they spend about $75,000 a year, including taxes.

Arthur and Naomi earn exactly the same. But they have a mortgage, they travel a lot, and they help their adult kids more than they planned to. They spend about $130,000 a year.

Both couples expect about $58,000 a year of combined Social Security at 67.

Pricing Retirement the Honest Way

Now let's price their retirements the honest way. Take what they spend, subtract Social Security, and that's the gap the portfolio has to fill every year for the rest of their lives.

  • Ray and Sakura: $75,000 − $58,000 = $17,000 a year
  • Arthur and Naomi: $130,000 − $58,000 = $72,000 a year

To turn that gap into a savings target, I'll use a 3.9% withdrawal rate. That's Morningstar's most recent estimate of a safe starting withdrawal rate for a 30-year retirement, at a 90% probability of not running out. You just divide the gap by 0.039.

  • Ray and Sakura: $17,000 ÷ 0.039 = about $436,000
  • Arthur and Naomi: $72,000 ÷ 0.039 = about $1.85 million

Same salary, same benchmark — and the honest number at 67 is more than four times higher for one couple than the other. How can a single chart be right for both of them? It can't.

Now, I want to be fair here, because there's a real reason these benchmarks use salary. Almost everybody knows what they earn. Almost nobody knows what they spend. A salary multiple is something you can calculate in your head at 35, and that's worth something.

But by 60, you have something much better than a salary. You have ten years of statements that tell you exactly how you live.

How to Measure Your Real Spending

When you pull those statements, be thorough. Leave out what disappears at retirement, like your 401(k) contributions and payroll taxes. Keep in the things budgets forget: the roof, the car you replace every eight years, the flights to see the grandkids. Here in Hawaii especially, I find people underestimate this number, because so many of the big costs are irregular. If you're going to be wrong, be wrong on the high side.

So the verdict: salary multiples overcharge the savers and undercharge the spenders. And if you've been a careful saver, the benchmark may be telling you you're further behind than you really are.

When Can I Retire? The Honest Number at 60

Everything so far assumed Social Security starts the day you retire. But if you stop working at 60, there's a stretch of years before that check arrives. I call it the bridge.

And at 60, the bridge is usually one of your most crucial numbers.

The Three Numbers You Need

  1. Your real spending, from your statements.
  2. The age you plan to start Social Security, which you can pull from your statement at ssa.gov.
  3. A realistic estimate for health insurance until Medicare starts at 65, because for most people retiring at 60, that's the one bill no employer is covering anymore.

Then you add two pieces together. The lifetime piece is the gap we just calculated, divided by 0.039. The bridge piece is your full spending for every year between retirement and Social Security, plus health insurance until 65.

Running It for Both Couples

Let's run it for both couples, retiring at 60 and claiming Social Security at 67.

Ray and Sakura:

  • Bridge: 7 years × $75,000 = $525,000
  • Health insurance, 60 to 65: 5 × $15,000 = $75,000
  • Lifetime piece: $436,000
  • Honest number to retire at 60: a little over $1 million

Arthur and Naomi:

  • Bridge: 7 years × $130,000 = $910,000
  • Health insurance, 60 to 65: $75,000
  • Lifetime piece: $1.85 million
  • Honest number to retire at 60: about $2.8 million

Now let's give them real balances, because this is where it gets personal. Say Ray and Sakura have $1.1 million saved. That's about seven times their salary, so the chart says they're behind. And say Arthur and Naomi have $1.3 million, closer to nine times their salary, so the chart says they're ahead.

The honest number says the opposite. Ray and Sakura are already past their number, and on these assumptions they could retire at 60 on what they have. Arthur and Naomi are less than halfway to theirs, and at their current spending, their realistic retirement date is closer to 66 or 67.

So which couple do you think has been lying awake at night? In my experience, it's usually Ray and Sakura. The savers are the ones the chart scares the most, and they're often the ones who need to worry the least.

A Few Honest Caveats

  • These figures are in today's dollars, and I gave the bridge money no growth, which is deliberately conservative.
  • Health insurance before 65 can cost much more or much less than $15,000 a year depending on your income. I cover this in detail in Health Insurance From 62 to 65.
  • Claiming Social Security earlier shrinks the bridge but lowers the check for life, which is its own decision with longevity and survivor tradeoffs.
  • The 3.9% rate assumes a 30-year retirement. If you're planning for longer, use a lower rate.

What to Do With Your Number

So now let's sort it out.

If Your Honest Number Is Below What You've Saved

The benchmark may have been making you feel behind for years when you weren't. That's worth sitting with, because the cost of believing you're behind isn't financial. It's the extra years you work for money your plan doesn't need.

And those years aren't interchangeable. Retirement may last 30 years, but it is not 30 equal years. The first ten to fifteen healthy, mobile years carry disproportionate value. If Ray and Sakura work to 63 because a chart said they were behind, they don't lose three years off the end of their retirement. They lose three years off the front — the years most capable of holding the trips and the time with family they've been saving for.

If Your Honest Number Is Above What You've Saved

Then here's the other half of the truth. That's not a verdict on you. It's a gap with a size, and a gap with a size can be closed. You can work a little longer, spend a little less in the bridge years, add part-time income for a few years, or rethink when you claim Social Security. Each of those moves shrinks the honest number in a way you can actually measure.

For Arthur and Naomi, the most powerful lever is spending. Every $10,000 a year they trim takes about $256,000 off the lifetime piece ($10,000 ÷ 0.039), plus another $70,000 off the seven-year bridge. So one change to how they live moves their honest number by roughly a third of a million dollars. That's not a punishment. It's a trade they get to look at with clear eyes, next to the option of working a few more years.

Either way, you'll know, and you'll know which lever to pull. That's a very different feeling from staring at a chart and wondering if you're failing. Knowing is the whole point. (For where a seven-figure balance actually ranks among your peers, see How Many Retirees Have $1.5 Million Saved?)

Your Salary Told You Where You Should Be

The 8x benchmark measures a salary. Your retirement doesn't spend a salary. It spends your life — your real monthly costs, over a real number of years, starting on the day you choose.

So here's the brutally honest truth. There's no multiple of your paycheck that tells you whether you've saved enough by 60. The only question that matters is the one underneath all of this: enough to do what, starting when?

The financial finish line isn't eight times anything. It's the point where your savings can fund the life you actually live, from the day you stop working. Some people crossed it without noticing, because the chart told them to keep running. And some are closer than they think, once they measure the right thing.

The gap you're feeling may not be financial at all. It may be permission you haven't given yourself yet.

Your salary told you where you should be. Your honest number tells you where you are.

If you'd like help building your honest number — with your real spending, your real Social Security estimates, and a plan for the bridge years — schedule a free consultation. I work with clients in Honolulu and virtually across the country. You can also start with the free Retirement Readiness Assessment.

— Daniel Masuda Lehrman, CFP®, Founder of Masuda Lehrman Wealth. Mahalo for reading.

Ray and Sakura and Arthur and Naomi are hypothetical examples for illustration only. They use simplified assumptions (today's dollars, no growth on bridge assets, an illustrative $15,000/year pre-65 health insurance cost and $58,000/year combined Social Security), do not represent actual clients, and do not guarantee any outcome. Fidelity's savings guideline and Morningstar's 3.9% estimate are cited as published by those firms; neither firm endorses Masuda Lehrman Wealth. This article is for educational purposes only and is not personalized financial, tax, or legal advice.

Free Guide: The Retirement Income Blueprint

Enjoyed this article? Get my free guide on turning your savings into a retirement paycheck you can't outlive — covering your income gap, withdrawal strategy, Social Security timing, and more.

About Daniel Masuda Lehrman, CFP®

Prior to starting my own firm, I was a Vice President Financial Consultant at Charles Schwab in their Downtown Honolulu office. I have worked in financial planning for 10 years at Vanguard, Fidelity, and Schwab. I'm a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ professional with an Economics degree from the University of Michigan.

Schedule a meeting